The Rural Patriot

September 29, 2006

UAW, Schweizer Employees, Charge Kuhl with False Advertising

Filed under: Randy Kuhl — theruralpatriot @ 9:47 am

(Editor note:  I received the following press release yesterday via my e-mail inbox.  I was waiting until I could verify before posting.  It is now verified, and I’m supplying three weblinks at the end of this post for your review.)

UAW, Schweizer Employees, Charge Kuhl with False Advertising; Officials and workers say misleading Kuhl ads falsely claim credit for Blackhawk jobs at Horseheads plant

Angry United Auto Workers representatives and employees from Schweizer Aircraft in Horseheads today charged Republican Congressman Randy Kuhl (NY-29) with claiming “jobs” credit he doesn’t deserve. Kuhl has an ad running on TV in the southeastern section of the 29th District, in which Kuhl touts his alleged achievements in bringing federal dollars into the district. In the ad, he also claims credit for bringing Blackhawk Helicopter jobs to the Schweizer facility.

UAW officials appeared in a press conference today in front of the Schweizer plant in Horseheads, and stated that it was a team approach by workers, union representatives, and Schweizer management that brought in the Blackhawk jobs and Kohl (sic) was not part of that process. UAW Local 1752 President Robert Huckle said that the effort began in 2002 with the formation of the joint process improvement program “Partners in Excellence”. The initiative involved “tremendous amounts of hard work, coordination, cooperation, and compromise from Union and Management, in order to make Schweizer Aircraft Corporation a world class manufacturing facility and the best place for the Blackhawk work to be produced. We worked long and hard to secure those jobs through process and efficiency improvements and for Randy Kuhl to claim credit for the resulting jobs amounts to false advertising.”

Workers at the press conference noted that since Kuhl is so clearly inflating his accomplishments in this area, it calls into question everything else he claims credit for in the ads. Like it said in the paper, in the [Elmira] Star Gazette: these ads are misleading. It’s pretty easy to announce a grant or an award and grab a headline. It takes a whole lot more to actually roll up your sleeves and make it happen in the first place.

Kuhl is locked in an intense battle for his seat in Congress against 24-year Navy veteran and Corning resident Eric Massa. The misleading ads rolled out last week as part of Kuhl’s campaign. Massa has been endorsed by a large number of unions, including the UAW.

Editor note: I was able to find this item from Congressman Kuhl’s website, dated 6/5/05:

…I also recently helped secure over $20 million to allow the Department of Homeland Security to purchase high-tech surveillance aircraft made by Schweizer Aircraft in Horseheads.

Supporting links:

UAW Workers Say Kuhl is Taking False Credit

“If he wants to continue running misleading ads, than that’s what he should do. If he wants to be honest with the public then he won’t take credit for things he didn’t do,” said UAW International Union Representative, Scott Montani.

UAW says Kuhl ad is wrong

Kuhl, in a statement, said the union is misinterpreting his ads and his Blackhawk references were meant to show the district’s job growth.

Big Flats — Schweizer union blasts Kuhl for Blackhawk ads

“The management and employees of Schweizer Aircraft and Sikorsky deserve all of the credit for landing the big contracts that they have, and I’ve been more than happy to help where I can,” Kuhl said in the statement.

At present, I’ve not been able to source Mr. Kuhl’s statement on the issue. I’ll keep looking and will link when or if it becomes available for on-line review.



  1. I got that press release, too, but I can’t find the ad they’re talking about. One of the stories said that it ran in the Southern part of the district. Maybe Kuhl has multiple versions of the “driving” ad running.

    Comment by Rottenchester — September 29, 2006 @ 3:26 pm | Reply


    Link for the ad including helicopter stuff. Kathy

    Comment by Kathy Bambrick — September 29, 2006 @ 5:59 pm | Reply

  3. Thanks Kathy! I had not seen that particular ad, either. On September 17, I had embedded an ad in this site, but it was a different one referencing the West Valley Nuclear Demonstration Facility where the “blackhawk” portion is in the ad that you provided.

    I appreciate your input.

    Comment by theruralpatriot — September 30, 2006 @ 10:04 am | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: